What is Jajmani system? Examine the views on Jajmani system as an egalitarian as well as exploitative system, Give reasons for its decline.
Umaharathi
The jajmani system was studied by william wiser through his village study of karimpura (U.P), presented in his work ( Hindu jajmani system).
concept and characteristics
1. system of exchange of goods + services between landowning upper castes and land less lower castes.
wiser studied + explain the phenomena with 24 castes in karimpura. 2. Characteristics from wiser's study - linked to caste based occupation - Hereditary + permanent - Means of maintenance (eg: puncharyat) [?] - conflict and cooperation - religious - cultural justification - involved multiple interactions
[a box of the letters J and K joined by arrows in several directions]
Jajmani system as egalitarian
1. william wiser highlighted the social economic security provided to landless Castes 2. pauline kolenda → gives rise to self sufficient village economies without exploitative competition. 3. Edmund leach - a practical division of labour. 4. MN Srinivas - Contributes to vertical caste solidarity, strengthening 'village patriotism'
Jajmani as exploitative
1. david Mandelbaum - rigid and linked to unchangeable, cast linked occupations 2. perpetuates inequity in land ownership - Continues till date (Daniel Thorner's agrarian relations) 3. Double exploitation & injustice of caste and class
| Jajman | Khamin | |---|---| | rich | poor | | uppercask | lower cack |
Reasons for decline of jajmani
1. Market economy, and purchase of services from market. for eg: Razor instead of Barber 2. Creation of surplus economy, as explained by A.K. Vasari
3. outmigration of khamins - D. Tilche's study in patidar - new economic opportunities in cities allowed landless to migrate 4. Economic upliftment of Dalit through modern economy. For eg. Dalit capitalism. 5. Legal measures - For eg. Minimum wag act, must pay labour in wage, not food grains 6. Chand + Srivastava study in Jagmod village Captured the decline due to monetisation of barter economy
In recent times scholars such as Daniel Miller argue that if explotative element are removed It can provide refuge in capitalist led alienation of labour (eg. In COVID- khamins could be taken care of)