Discuss theories for decline of Indus Valley Civilization.
Umaharathi
Indus valley civilization was India's Bronze age, and first urban civilization that flourished along valley of indus between 3300 - 1500BCE.
[a rough map of the geographical extent of the IVC with Harappa, Kalibangan, Mohenjodaro and Lothal marked]
Fig: Geographical extent of IVC
Decline of IVC
- The civilization disappeared rather suddenly around 1500 BCE. - This is intriguing given the cultural progress of the IVC - several scholars put forward their theories
1. Aryan invasion theory - supported by Ridley, R E M wheeler. - overpowered by immigrant Aryans - Evidence shown as reference to battle in Rigveda, and presence of offensive weapons in archeological finds
Criticism: No mass burials, waves of Aryan migration, Decline started before the battle mentioned in Rigveda 2. Climate change theory - Sudden change in climate led to disappearence of rivers, pushing IVC to decline
Criticism: inadequate geomorphic evidence. 3. Tectonic theory - by Raikes + Dales - Massive earthquake destroyed the Biogrography.
Criticism: No evidence of such massive tectonic Phenomena 4. Hydrological theory - V.N Misra's view. Drying up of Chaggar resulted in declined flow in Indus, pushing agriculture to decline.
Criticism - inadequate evidence to link it just to Chaggar drying 5. Black lightening theory - by Dmitryev - Black lightening event resulted in chemical explosion. - Evidence of blackened rocks, and crouched bodies. - Criticism - inadequate evidence. 6. Mughal + Ghosh argued that IVC didn't disappeared but declined into post Harappan cultures. These were rural + regionally diverse.
Today no single theory explains the decline, but it is believed 'multi-factor' theory makes more sense, as all the above factors may have contributed.