India was forced into numerous wars post Independence. Highlight the causes and impact of the Indo-Pak and Indo-China wars on our bilateral relationships.
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
India was forced into wars in 1947-48, 1962, 1965, 1971 and in 2001, with Pakistan and China, post independence.
| War | Causes | |---|---| | 1947-48, "infantry day war", immediately post independence | Pakistan sending mercenaries to Kashmir despite Raja Hari Singh having decided he would not join either dominion. This led to Hari Singh signing Instrument of Accession with India. India intervened | | 1962 war, war with China | Intrusion by China into Indian territory, both Aksai Chin and Arunachal. Genocide of Tibetans | | 1965, war with Pak | Intrusion in Rann of Kutch. Operation Gibraltar by Pak: sending troops to J&K. Operation Grand Slam: large scale armed attack | | 1971 war (with Pak), liberation of Bangladesh | Operation Search Light by Pak: genocide of people in Bangladesh. Declaration of war against India. Humanitarian and refugee crisis in Assam | | 2001 war (Kargil) | Intrusion in regions of Kargil, Dras, Batalik, etc (post winter season). Violation of bilateral agreements |
Impact on India-Pak relations:
1. Breakdown of trust 2. Unsettled, militarised borders (eg:) LoC 3. Highest militarized point globally: Siachen 4. Lack of connectivity between nations 5. Lack of trade between India, Pak: (World Bank report) "A glass half full", South Asia rated as least connected globally 6. Use of terrorism by Pakistan as matter of foreign policy 7. Distressed existence for people living along border, especially in places such as Gilgit Baltistan in PoK, Poonch, Rajouri, etc in India
Impact on India-China relations:
1. Border disputes: McMahon Line v/s Johnson Line 2. Rising militarization of borders (eg:) rapid Chinese construction of infra, rapid Chinese accumulation of troops, counter accumulation in India 3. Impacting other facets of relationship (eg:) trade, people-to-people exchange, etc 4. Denial of visas to each other's citizens
As EAM Jaishankar has said, "Peace and stability at borders is essential for relationship to move forward".