Examine the utility of the concepts of Sanskritisation and Westernisation in understanding Indian Society.
Sachin Gupta
Robert Redfield considered to be a pioneer in village studies, when he conducted his first study in 1930. On similar lines, Mysore Narsimhachar Srinivas considered as pioneer in village studies post Independence.
MN Srinivas, gave the concept of Sanskritization and Westernization in his article, " Sanskritization and Westernization " in 1956 after studying the Coorg of Mysore.
Sanskritization :- is a two step process in which at first place lower castes or tribals tries to imitate the rituals and living pattern of higher caste. In second stage they try to claim the higher status in local caste hierarchy after building solidarity with local higher caste.
Similarly, Westernization :- is the process of imitation of western life style by Indians social system to build solidarity with higher class and stratification from lower class
Utility of Concepts
1. Social Reality :- with these Concept MN Srinivas was able to project the field View of Indian Social System, which is not rigid and as prescribed by Louis Dumont through Book Viewe. MN Srinivas, gave examples in his book "Social change in India" in 1956 , of Sanskritization in India. like Noniyas belongs to lower" Caste Status in local Caste hierarchy with improvement in economic position with through British patronage , they raised their status from 33 to 17 in local Caste hierarchy. Thus highlighting the mobility the social system like class System of west 2. Impact of British Rule:- The profound impact of westernization came only after British ruled India , which is even carried forward in post independent India. With western education System , Britishers tried to diffused their living style , which was readily adapted by educated and highly caste people . Thus further increasing structural complexity in Indian Social System 3. Dominant Caste :- The process of imitation of cultural traits and claiming higher status, ultimately leads to Dominant Caste Status, however in this dominant caste not neccessarily adapts the ritnds of higher caste. Later, Dominant Caste becomes a model of Sanskritization. 4. with Westernization ;- the transport system, media, the diffusion of traits is spreading at faster place. Hence it fastens the speed of Sanskritization in Society
Criticism
However, Sanskritization and Westernization are not symmetric & pan India process. For e.g. In Uttar Pradesh, the Sanskritization took place through westernized model like the wearing Hat, western style of clothing. On the other hand, South India it occurs through Sacred thread ceremony.
Similarly, Secondly, in Owen Lynch studied Jatavas of UP, they are not able to claim higher status in local caste hierarchy even after imitating but created further stratification in lower caste hierarchy, which cannot be explained by concept of MN Srinivas
Thirdly, D N Majumdar, studied the Khasa, where [?] 5 higher caste [?] merged together in Khasas, and claim tribal status to which be called Desanskritization.
However, MN Srinivas, but with his structural functional approach in field studies provided the ground realities and social undercurrents which are governing the social change in Indian society.