Fifth and Sixth Schedules in Indian Constitution.
Sachin Gupta
Intro. Tribal Administration was largely maintained through Vth and VIth Schedule mentioned in Article 243 and 244 of Constitution of Part IX. It owes its origin from British periods when "Scheduled Districts" consisting of tribals are found in 1874. Then in 1919, they came up with :-
(i) Wholly excluded area
(ii) Area with modified exclusion.
Further in 1935, it was converted to
(i) Partially excluded Area
(ii) Wholly excluded Area.
which are under overall control of Governor
Vth Schedule
Constitutes of areas in 9 tribal states of India, recognized as "tribal areas" and require special attention :-
(i) Governor can change or modify the laws passed by legislature or parliament in Scheduled Areas.
(ii) Governor secures them land from alienation by checking any transfer of land to non-tribal.
(iii) Activities of moneylender are prohibited.
(iv) PESA was applicable here which recognizes authority of Gram Sabha as well as traditional leaderships.
(v) Right over community property are observed.
(vi) Tribal Advisory Council was constituted having 3/4th of tribals. to advice State government on policies.
(vii) Governor has to submit reports regarding administration of Schedule 5th areas to President.
However, Xaxa Committee observes, Governor due to political pressure, ineffective to protect land alienation.-
(i) MP land regulation rules of 1959 are still in place which authorizes transfer of land to non-tribals.
(ii) Chattisgarh still didn't prohibit acquisition of land on minute loan default of tribals.
(iii) Bhuria Committee observes, Submitted reports are largely copy-paste, not were issues are discussed. Shows indifferent approach.
(iv) Rajasthan doesn't recognize traditional authority and autonomy is further eroded as District Administration can overturn Gram Sabha decision.
(v) Tribal Advisory Council largely remain political body fails to uphold tribal rights.
VIth Schedule
Constitutes the specific areas of Assam, Mizoram, Tripura & Meghalya. :-
(i) It has Autonomous District Council and regional council for governance in tribal these regions.
(ii) Wide range of powers and Authority is delegated like managing shifting cultivation, moneylending, judicial powers as per tradition, management of forest, education, health. Even allowed taxation from people to manage there achivities.
However, Xaxa Committee observes that :-
(i) Financially these council don't have adequate resources to fulfill all its responsibilites.
(ii) Larger tribal groups like Bodo's discriminate smaller groups like Rabha in District Council
(iii) No time limit has been given for reconstitution of Council if dissolved.
(iv) Judicial powers are misused.
Hence there is need to reform Vth and VIth Schedule to achieve the goal for which constituted.