Topper Copies

Write an essay comparing the theoretical and field aspects of L P Vidyarthi and M N Srinivas.

Sachin Gupta

LP Vidyarthi and MN Srinivas are the two stalwarts of Indian Anthropology which enhanced the scope of discipline in India.

Theoretical Comparison - LP Vidyarthi is a student of DN Majumdar, who later went to Columbia University at Chicago to do fellowship and influenced with American School of Anthropology after working with Sol Tax, Julian Steward & Robert Redfield. - However, MN Srinivas chose Masters in Sociology and integrated the discipline with GS Ghurye under social anthropology. He was influenced with British School of Anthropology especially Structural-Functionalism of Radcliffe Brown - Cultural Ecology :- LP Vidyarthi influenced with American School gave a concept of Nature-Man-spirit complex. which highlights the [?] Culture as as aspect of ecology after studying the Mater community.

- However, M N Srinivas gave concepts of Sanskritization, westernization, explained with structural functional perspective. That society as a whole functions to maintain its structure. Different groups interacts with each other. in Society. [?] - Although both agrees with the school of diffusion, that cultural traits transfers from one place to another. as communities came into contact with each other. Here MN Srinivas explained imitation as a [?] step in sanskritization or westernization. LP Vidyarthi, gave the concept of Sacred Complex, in which Sacred Specialist performs major role in diffusion of cultural traits.

Field Aspects Both LP Vidyarthi and MN Srinivas believed in fieldwork tradition through participant observation method. However:-

1. Tribal v/s Rural:- LP Vidyarthi concentrated more on tribals in its field work and MN Srinivas studied Indian mainstream society as a main focus of his field studies. 2. Social v/s Political:- LP Vidyarthi field aspects largely concentrates to social upliftment and social condition on tribals. MN Srinivas took interest in understanding with political changes like Dominant social phenomenon Caste in his field work of Rampura in his book "Dominant Caste in Rampura" (1959) 3. Urban v/s Village - LP Vidyarthi after studying the impact of urbanization and industrialization on tribal in his book "Socio-Cultural Implication of Industrialization in India." in 1970 with Hatia - Industrial complex and corresponding impact. - MN Srinivas : village studies deciphers the socio-cultural process going on, changing the character of villages. It highlights the importance of recognization of traditional authorities to implement policies.

However, both [?] with their field aspects gave the broad outlines of Indian Civilization and Socio-cultural changes taking place with westernization, urbanization and Industrialization in India.

Thus giving the scope of applied and action anthropology to utilize the understanding and uplift the Society by increasing the efficiency & effectiveness of government policies and Scheme.