Post modernism
Sachin Gupta
Post modernism is a tradition / School of anthropology that came into reaction of Modern School who tried to find scientific of theory of cultural evolution / functioning, which actually dehumanizes the human society.
Post Modern school criticizes the other schools on two accounts :-
1. Ideological level 2. Epistemological level
Ideological Level :- At ideological level, it says Science is concentrated in the hands of few sections of Society which utilizes the Scientific knowledge in their benefits rather than human upliftment. For example :- Colonial leaders used the anthropological understanding in further exploiting the economic resources and indigenous communities in their benefit.
Epistemological level :- that simply means "method of gathering data".
Post Modern School of Anthropology criticizes the Participant Observation Method as it questions the objectivity of data. It says the data collected by anthropologist has its own bias. For ex, Restudies conducted at Trobriand Islanders highlighted that Malinowski neglected the role of women played in society. Similarly, restudy conducted by Derek Freeman on Samoa after "Coming of Age in Samoa" by Margaret Mead, he highlighted the subjectivity and misplaced arguments by Margaret Mead. However, it still remains debatable, today in anthropology.
Further, post modern school uses the methods of:-
1. Deconstruction:- Deconstruct the thought process, and study the societies as it is & collect the data. 2. Humanizing the process of data collection:- (Post structuralist) it says data should not be tried to fit into predecided Structural understanding of Mind. 3. Find new process, to collect data which can improve the gathering of data process.
Criticism 1. Roy D Andrade criticizes the Post modernist (PM) that completely value neutral ethnographies is impossible. However its the duty of Anthropologist to come up with objective facts as much as possible 2. Extreme Relativism can lead to Nihilism that is not desirable for Social discipline like anthropology 3. It undermines the importance of universal human Rights, being extremely Cultural relativism in nature.
It can be concluded with Spiro argument that intellectual knowledge gives power which comes with responsibility to build empathy towards others and utilize it for human upliftment. to solve the caution of PM