Compare and contrast German and American Diffusionism.
Sachin Gupta
Diffusion school of Anthropology basis its studies upon cultural traits passed from one area to another. Its basic tenets are:-
1. Man is an uninventive individuals cultural traits develops at particular place due to reasonable favourable condition. 2. Cultural traits travels from one area to another based upon its utility 3. Trade between communities, Christian missionaries plays important in transfering culture from one place to another. i.e. Diffusion of cultural traits
Methodology Diffusionist utilizes different sets of methodologies along with technique to unravel the data.
1. Comparative Method is used to highlight similarities and differences. 2. Participant observation i.e. primary source of data collection is used along with Secondary methods like histories compiled by travellers, missionaries etc.
Three schools of Diffusion developed In anthropology i.e.
1. British school led by Smith & Perry & WHR Rivers. 2. German School led by Ratzel 3. American School led by Clark Wissler and Kroeber.
Differences between German and American School of Diffusion 1. Cultural Centre :- German School gave a concept of "Kulture kreis" from which cultural trait transfers one way.
[a drawn diagram of concentric circles labelled "Culture kreis", beside a dashed circle with arrows from a central circle outward to small circles, showing one-way transfer of traits from the centre]
However American School takes about Cultural Area. two way diffusion of Cultural traits from culture centre. 2. Invention of Cultural Traits :- German school doesn't give reason behind invention of particular cultural trait. But American School gave the concept of food Area that induces the invention of broad cultural trait. - Deer in Tundra Region —— Eskimo. (Tundra Region) - Maize —— Eastern America. 3. Measurement :- German school measures the diffusion by Similarity of trait (form) and no. of similar traits to measure the amount of diffusion. while American School gave the concept of food area and age area to as a criteria of diffusion. 4. Process of Diffusion :- German School of diffusion, believes in direct contact and trade as process of diffusion. While American School takes ecology as well as assymetric diffusion of traits through colonialism also into consideration along with direct sources.
Similarities 1. Anti Heliocentric: Both the school Criticized the Heliocentric idea of British school of diffusion. That Egypt is the Centre of all the invention of trait from there it transferred to other places. 2. Both schools emphasized on fieldwork tradition to decipher the facts. to make their analysis scientific. 3. Both believed in "cultural determinism" that is culture that was shaped by human thought and needs not biology. 4. Inductive Approach :- Both carried the inductive approach of cultural studies, gathering the data and then analyzing to get results. 5. Both Schools, highlighted the importance of diffusionism in studying the culture of different societies. As its a amending process.
Despite differences and Similarities, school of diffusion gave a different perspective to study cultural traits and their transmission from place. It is even relevant today in understanding the conditions of tribals in India depending upon diffusion of outside traits and also various phenomenon of Sanskritization, westernization in mainstream society.