Topper Copies

Bring about the arguments related to Ethnocentrism vs Cultural Relativism.

Sachin Gupta

Ethnocentrism and Cultural Relativism are the ways through with anthropologist studied various societies.

Ethnocentrism :- studies the culture of different societies from the perspective of its own cultural construct and give value judgements over there socio-cultural practices. Its a etic approach.

Cultural Relativism :- is a reactionary perspective to ethnocentrism, which argues for studying the culture as "what it is" from the perspective of society, and doesn't believe in giving value loaded judgements. Its a emic perspective,

In anthropology, debate has been there regarding how anthropologist should go for ethnographic fieldwork, various arguments are laid by both the Schools:-

Cultural Relativism:-

1. Objectivity:- Cultural Relativist argues, by viewing culture as it is, we will be able to gather "social fact" which helps in building objectivity and scientific theory of culture. 2. Every culture is unique:- One cannot have superiority and inferiority regarding cultural values and norms. 3. Adaptation:- Cultural Relativist argues, culture is just an adaptation to on ecological condition, rather than giving a value for judgement, we should analyze why certain cultural trait exist in that ecological condition.

Ethnocentricism :-

Initially, ethnocentricism was discarded as an approach to study as it was thought it brings biasedness. But in recent times its gaining :-

1. Human Rights debate :- Neo Ethno-centrist believes, anthropological studies meant from human welfare, if certain cultural traits include human right violation, we need to views from global shared perspective. Otherwise even cannabalism of Eskimo, Sati system of Hindu Society could be justified. 2. Neo ethnography:- with rise of neo ethnography, Marvin Harris propagated the view that we need both emic and etic views. Rather than discarding the ethnocentrist approach we need to integrate with cultural relativism for holistic understanding.

In contemporary period; central idea remains action & applied anthropology. Rather than compartmentalizing both the approaches, we use both of them for holistic understanding and moving for removal various inhuman acts / cultural practices.