Topper Copies

'Nothing is wrong with Consanguineous marriages'. Comment.

Sachin Gupta

Consanguineous marriage can be defined as "marriage between close relatives". Genetically, "mating between same gene pool."

There has been arguments on both sides that "consanguineous marriage is harmful or not".

Proponents gave argument based upon studies on particularly vulnerable tribal groups like Great Andamanese, whose population is decreasing in last century due to inbreeding:

- As inbreeding increases homozygosity, the genotype changes to phenotype; - The moment, it was lethal or sublethal or semilethal mutation at any point. Even a recessive lethal mutation will show phenotype and corresponding decrease in population. Hence its harmful

Parent generations => Tt x Tt

TT : Tt : Tt : tt = 1 : 2 : 1

| Generation | Homozygous | Heterozygous | Homozygous | |---|---|---|---| | F_1 | [?]·1/4 | [?]·1/2 | [?]·1/4 | | F_2 | 3/8 | 1/4 | 3/8 | | F_3 | 7/16 | 1/8 | 7/16 | | F_4 | 15/32 | 1/16 | 15/32 | | ⋮ | ⋮ | ⋮ | ⋮ | | F_n. | 1/2 | 0 | 1/2 |

[?] As per this argument, shown by above diagram, inbreeding reduces the genetic diversity which again act as a threat to stability and survival of particular genetic pool.

Above arguments sound plausible and have genetic basis also to prove consanguinous marriage are harmfull.

But these are based upon argument that if there is a lethal mutation that can result in genetic load and leading to extinction of population

In anthropology, as a scientific discipline, theories cannot be based upon "if". However should have universal applicability.

Further, National Institute of Biomolecular genetics of West Bengal studied the South Asian population especially Indian population, found that Caste endogamy has not always resulted in genetic load. Fitness of a population only decreased when there is a genetic mutation that has been passed to next generation. Hence, inbreeding is harmfull cannot be rule.

Secondly, the argument laid by decrease in genetic diversity reduces the fitness of genetic pool is still to be proven scientifically.

Even, the basing argument on specific tribal groups like Great Andamanese have stablize their population at same level. are still practcing consanguinous marriage. Their population was decreasing due to lack of anthropological approach towards them and constant exploitation. In recent times that ca has been charged with introduction of anthropologists. in implementing policies towards them.

So, we can conclude that, consanguineous marriages are not harmfull and nothing wrong is there in them. unless and until gene pool doesn't have any corresponding lethal mutation in respective environment.