"Germany is to be a great extent held responsible for causing both the first and the second World Wars." Critically discuss.
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
The two world wars in 1914 and 1939 are called total wars by many historians due to their huge ramifications in almost all fields. Germany as a nation, was singularly involved in major part of the these conflict in both these wars. These leads to historians placing the responsibility on Germany.
German Responsibility for W.W. I - Role of Bismarckian foreign policy of cutting off France while creating a system of secret alliances. (eg three Emperor Alliance, etc.) - Role of rising Germany that destabilised european balance of power by its fast industrialization and entry into race for colonies - Role of German Kaiser Wilhem's Weltpolitik and his aggressive militarisation (naval race with England) and foreign policy (dealings with morocco) - Blank cheque given by Germany to Austria during Serbian conflict - Miscalculations by general Moltke regarding Schieffel Plan and war preparedness
Other's responsibility: Other historians are of the opinion that nations like Austria (for their aggressive nationalism and treatment of Balkans) and Russia (for their readiness to jump in, aid of Pan-Slav) were also responsible for the war
German responsibility in WW II - Role of Hitler in achieving his ideas of lebensraum and Third Reich by attacking Poland and breaking assurances with England and France - German - Japan - Italy alliance of steel pact to counter Western Nations and Russia
Other's Responsibility : - According to historian A.J.P. Taylor, Hitler did not want a world war, he was satisfied with a small war with Poland - It was actually Britain and France that declared war on Germany and it represented how they would always neglect world peace for personal gains - Failure of League of Nations, Locarno treaty and the dictated peace that had led to resentment among Germany post Versailles Treaty - Role of Russia, accordig to Western authors due to Stalin signing non-confrontation pact with Hitler
while Germany cannot be made to hold full responsibility, they were substantially responsible for political situations that led to both wars.