Critically examine the extent upto which the League of Nations became successful with proper examples.
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
League of Nations was an International organisation formed post World War I with the goal to ensure such conflict never happens again by aiding in diplomatic resolution of fights between Nations.
League of Nations record has been chequered with failures and successes in different measures.
Record of failures and their reasons - born out of Treaty of Versailles which was in itself highly controversial and a dictated peace - absence of important nations like - USA, Germany (till 1924) / USSR (till 1934), etc - inability to enforce its decisions on nation states due to lack of standing army - run more as a Britain-France show with aims to fulfill their diplomatic aims (eg) Role in Mandate System being imposed in Middle East - Failure in responding to Italian invasion of Abbysinia and Japanese invasion of Manchuria which show-cased complete helplessness of league - Failure in its core goal of preventing another World War (eg) World War II in 1939
Despite these failures the league had some big successes that allowed it to leave its footprint on the history of world.
Successes - Resolution of inter-nation issues - league was able to resolve all issues presented to it except 2 mentioned earlier - for instance: - Dispute between finland and Sweden - South American issue between Peru and Colombia - Greek war on Bulgaria, etc - Role of its committees in promoting human rights and world integration eg Refugee convention - during Nazi holocaust by aiding those who escaped - ILO → in ensuring labour rights and better working conditions - Health Committee → in ensuring spread of Typhus and greater advances in medical science - Beyond all that, League was the first step in creating an International Political Organisation, which in itself was monumentous - Moreover, it provided a blueprint of what not to do and what can be improved which was used by UN later on
Thus, League of Nations while not as much of a success as envisioned, still was able to ensure that efforts for world peace are strengthened.