Critically evaluate Barani's account as a source of history of Medieval India during Delhi Sultanate.
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
Ziaud-din Barani has been referred to as scholar-cum-historian par excellence of Sultanate era.
His works Tarikh-e-firozshahi is a source of history of 7 kings of Delhi.
Positives 1. Starts right from where Minhas Siraz left. 2. Was closely associated with the throne in some capacity and thus had first hand knowledge 3. Covers whole gamut of activities - policies, achievements, conquests and failures. 4. Tackles issues in a whole and breaks down them in all dimensions in a lucid, intelligent manner. 5. uses various sources to compare, contrast and provide an insight on the mind of the rulers 6. Similarly, his other work, Fatwa-i-jahandari acts as companion to Tarikh-i-ferozshahi and provides info. on ideas of governance, secular order (Zawabit); focus on justice and also gives advices to kings on following Siyasat instead of Shariat.
Limitations of Barni 1. Biased presentation of Muhammad-Bin-Tughlaq's reign. 2. Firuz Shah's era was produced under duress 3. Extreme religious views 4. Deficient in dates and written from memory.