Q.8(b) On one hand, Gandhiji withdrew the Non-Cooperation Movement on the issue of violence at Chauri-Chaura but on the other hand he had refused to condemn people's violence during the Quit India Movement. Does it show that he was losing faith in the efficacy of non-violence and was willing to deviate from this path?
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
In February, 1922, at Chauri Chaura a group of protesters attacked a police station and while the Non-cooperation movement was in full swing. This violent attack led to Gandhiji calling off the full-swing movement which was in full-swing movement as he had launched the movement on the basis of Non-violence. But despite the various violent outbursts and uncontrolled streams that signified the quit India movements, Gandhiji refused the British governments asking of condemning the violence.
This didnot mean that he was losing faith in non-violence as:
1. he refused to condemn because - the violence by the people was a reaction to the leonine violence of the state with draconian powers of wartime. 2. Overtime, Gandhi through his movements and constructive programs had taught the masses how to launch and sustain a movement. 3. Where in, in 1921, the masses / movements were new to mass non-violence way and thus important, by 1942 the situation was very different 4. The masses now were ready and at their end with British raj and Gandhi being a mass leader understood their mentality. 5. Moreover, it is said that 1942, found even Gandhi in a strongely militant mood. 6. He was unsatisfied with British and he had even given the mantra - do or die. 7. Moreover, even before the movement, he had told people that he would not ask them to follow non - violent creed and rather asked them to do as they pleased.
Moreover, this was not a deviation from his path as:
1. he had always believed that violence was preferable to cowardice and actions of people represented the very same. 2. Moreover more than non-violence the people's actions were for Satyagraha and that made them just.
And Gandhi continued to showcase his efficacy and belief in non-violence even later on during and after Partition (eg. at Noakhali), Thus, the actions of gandhi were not a crisis of faith rather a rebuttal of the British policy of brutal repression.