Q.5(d) "The modern Indian Renaissance had continuing importance of religion and philosophy and there is as much reason for regarding it as a reformation as there is for treating it as a Renaissance." Critically examine.
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
Indian renaissance refers to the 19th century socio-religious reform movements that emerged out of Bengal and tried to spread [?] Enlightenment ideas.
Continued importance of religion & philosophy
- The movements retained importance of religion & philosophy as they were a reaction to attack of colonial cultural hegemony on Indian religion & philosophy. - they stood for strengthening, reviving and reforming native religious traditions. [?] Brahmo & Arya Samaj. - the reviving of past glory was intertwined as Indian culture is deeply seeped in Religion and philosophy.
movement as Reformation or Renaissance.
| Reformation (historian: Sumit Sarkar) | Renaissance (historian: S.Sircar) | |---|---| | focus was on reforming cultural practices. | focus on rationalism and humanism. | | evil attributes were excised and traditions strengthened | ideas of creation of Universal religion, | | limited development of art, sciences, etc | rejection of Miracles. | | (eg) Arya Samaj, Vivekanada, etc | belief in modernity visible in letting go of tradition and accepting modern sciences. | | | (eg) Brahmo Samaj |
Thus, the movement essentially was the best of both worlds. and tried to incorporate elements from both to create a modern Indian society.