Q.4(a) "Though the Act of 1919 was superseded by that of 1935, the preamble to the former was not repealed-the preservation of the smile of the Cheshire cat after its disappearance, and the latter said nothing about Dominion Status." Elucidate.
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
Government of India Act (GOI), 1935 superseded the GOI Act, 1919 and became the 'new constitution' for British India in its last phase. While this act of 1935 superseded 1919, as seen by its provisions of:
1. removal of dyarchy from provinces -> instead Provincial autonomy proposed. 2. All India federation at centre with 40% seats for the princes in Central legislature. 3. Dyarchy retained for centre with similar Reserved and Transfered subject distribution. 4. establishment of federal courts, separation of burma, abolition of council of Secretary of State, etc.
But, it had one ambiguity, which was - no preamble provided for the act. Thus, in its place the preamble of 1919 was retained while the rest of the act was repealed.
This represented the persistence of smile even when the Cheshire cat disappeared as:
1. the preamble only talked of gradual development of self- governing institutions in India. 2. But instead of acting on the preamble and providing for a 'dominion' status', as demanded, the act allowed for retaining the former.
This represented the British attitude of:
1. Not having any intention of providing autonomy any time soon. 2. belief in British political circles that Indians were incapable of running the country! eg Lord Birkenhead's challenge a few years earlier. 3. Further, this looked to Indians as just another clumsy compromise and a complete disregard to their voices.
furthermore, the act remains deficient in many other areas as:
1. it failed to provide any fundamental rights 2. Its 'safegaurds' gave even more dictatorial powers to british government. 3. The all india federation, meant to cripple congress, never came into being as Princes refused to agree. 4. Moreover reality of responsible government in provinces remained half-full as executive still worked under directions of Governor.
Thus JL Nehru rightly called it - "all brakes and no engine"