Q.3(c) "By granting Muslims separate electorates the Imperial power institutionalized their division from other Indians." Comment.
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
In 1906, Muslim league was formed, as a platform to secure Muslim secular interests. When a delegation of them went to lord minto and secured the proposal of separate electorates - it officially began the process of communalisation of Indian society. Separate electorates for Muslims in GOI act 1909, ensured that in each constituency two different representatives shall be elected by different religious communities, that would look after their separate interests. [?] It institutionalised their division from other Indians as:
- Muslim secular interests were now officially different from others. - Moreover, 'governance of Muslims only by Muslims' was accepted which was later used by Jinnah to break down talks at Shimla conference or Interim Government - The idea of muslims from a minority to muslims a separate class of people emerged. - This was later crystallised into the '2 nation theory' wherein Muslims would need their 'homeland'.
Thus, it's rightly said that the 'seeds of Pakistan' were sowed in the GoI act of 1909, that allowed separate electorates.