Topper Copies

Q.3(a) "Why did the British finally quit India on 15th August 1947? The imperialist answer is that independence was simply the fulfilment of British self-appointed mission to assist the Indian people to self-government." Critically Examine.

Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023

On 15th August 1947, after almost 200 years of rule, the British finally left India. Different historians have put forward different reasons for this in their historiography:

1. Imperialist historians (all British ones)

They are of the belief that it was the culmination of the process of promised self-government to the people of India, as written in the preamble of Government of India Act, 1919. It was also regularly reiterated by various statesmen like Ramsay Mcdonald.

2. Cambridge school of Historians (Reps. like Anil Seal)

They are of the view that India was freed because of domestic constraint. That India by that time had become a burden for british, it had no gaing and a better option was to just leave India.

3. Labour party's parting gift (Reps. like Karl bridge)

Party under Atlee had already made the promise in 1935 election and many members were in favor of that. Thus, they followed through and gave India freedom,

4. John darwin's view

He believes that it was the nationalist struggle of the colonies that led to freedom. In particular the radical manifestations of nationalism that forced the British hand.

Beyond that, the changed International Scenario post world war II, represented by:

1. weakened european powers 2. Atlantic Charter before war 3. rise of two new superpowers that believed in decolonisation

resulted in the British finally deciding to leave India in 1947.

Moreover, nationalist historians have also raised questions on the views put forward by Imperialist or British historians and they contest that :

1. British self-appointed mission of self-governance was nothing but a manifestation of White Racism and White man's Burden 2. Further, India remained the most important colony for britain till their withdrawal. 3. Furthermore, so by 1945, labour party itself wasn't in favour of giving up India completely.

Thus, it was more a result of multifaceted Indian National Movement that british exited on 15th August 1947.