Topper Copies

Q.1(b) 'Clive was not a planner of empire, but an experimenter who revealed some of the possibility.' Critically examine.

Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023

Robert Clive was a clerk in East India company (EIC) who through his entrepreneurial spirit and daring helped turned the fortune of EIC, first in south and then in Bengal through Battle of Plassey.

Not a planner | but an experimenter :

- Clive couldn't be called a planner because his actions in war were more of individual heroics and luck that aided the British. - Moreover his Dual Rule in Bengal was more of an experiment due to company not wanting real control and they experiment when successful revealed the possibility of an empire building. - His actions with Mir Zafar, then removing him with Mir Qasim, his betrayal and finally reinstating Mir Zafar show - he was more reactionary than a planner. - The failure of dual rule and its impact on company finances leading to Regulating Act of 1773 further showcase this.

But, it'd be a disservice to completely disregard his planning as -

1. his attack on Arcot which won them the Carnatic war 2. His diplomatic tactics - in turning french; sending Dupleix home and with Plassey show a keen mind.

Thus Clive while not a good administrator was a better soldier and diplomat.