"The overriding powers of the Governor diluted the spirit of autonomy brought by the Government of India Act of 1935 by replacing diarchy with provincial autonomy." Elucidate.
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
Government of India Act 1935, emerged out of the white Paper deliberation of Simon Commission and third Round table conference.
Diluted the spirit of autonomy - 1935 act had replaced dyarchy in provinces with autonomy wherein responsible government was to be established - this would ensure ministers having greater powers -> (example) - no arbitrary division of revenue and transferred lists - greater powers to legislate and vote on budget
but this was diluted due to powers of governor, which allowed : - governor to pass ordinances - governor to make regulation for peace and prosperity of region - governor to refuse assent to bill or reserve it for assent of governor-general - governor to remove ministers - governor incharge of non-vot[?] part of budget - governor as eventual head of administration
Thus, this ensured that autonomy presented remained ephemeral especially in coalition provinces.
Rightfully J.L. Nehru called it - " an engine with all brakes and no power. "