Topper Copies

"The rise and expansion of British empire was an accident rather than the result of a deliberate policy and design". Critically examine.

Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023

The above statements reflect the various debates that have emerged on the historio-graphy of rise and expansion of British empire in India.

Viewpoint I Held by many British historians including Marshall, Ramsay and John Seeley.

- Seeley: British empire was done blindly and accidentally, in a fit of absentmindedness. British Company had no interest and only due to prevailing political uncertainity was forced to annex - Ramsay Muir: EIC was forced to step in against its will. And even then they provided infinite service to Indian princes - Marshall → it was not directed by Home government and rather due to actions of company officers on ground

View 2 By Balakrishnan in 1950s-60s completely refuted above view and asserted that company always had a plan to build empire and executed it step by step.

View 3 By other Historians after detailed studies post 1970s.

In 17th century company might have had only commercial interests but by 18th century they had developed imperial ambitions. In this they were aided (Financially & militarily) and guided by Metropole.

Thus, the above statement stands refuted by new evidence and historiography.