What factors caused the failure of the League of Nations? Is it correct to say that the League was a complete failure and irrelevant in the World history? Discuss.
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
League of Nations is an Intergovernmental organisation founded under the Paris Peace Conference after the end of first world war.
But while the core function of the league was to maintain world peace, the league failed spectacularly in its endeavour as seen from the 2nd world war
causes of failure of league :
1. too closely linked with the Treaty of Versailles → thus had a bad impression as a league of and by victors 2. US refused to join league - big blow to its standings 3. Other big powers like Germany & Russia were not involved initially 4. No real powers to enforce its decisions. 5. Poor charter framework. 6. Considered more of a french and british led conference 7. Failure to control and even criticise imperialistic actions like japan in china, Italy in Ethiopia, etc.
All of these factors combined to allow for the biggest 'black mark' in Leagues annals, which was the 2nd world war. Hitler was allowed to pretty much do whatever he pleased and further appeased by league members. All of this led to league not being taken seriously. At the same time, it would be wrong to call league a complete failure and irrelevant to the world history as:
1. Provided an experimental set-up for the league's successor - United Nations. - as the failures of league were analysed to strengthen the institution. 2. Many of its committees and co-organisations did stellar work, s.a: ILO, Health orgn' and Refugee organisation. 3. It was even able to resolve some political disputes which were referred to it, such as: - (a) quarrel between Finland and Sweden over some islands. - (b) Greek invasion of Bulgaria - (c) squabbles b/w Peru and Colombia. 4. It was able to ensure 20 years of peace.
Thus, while the league wasn't a success, it was successful in demonstrating the need of international collaboration to ensure peace.