What was the nature of French Revolution? Discuss by giving various views.
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
French revolution began in 1789 by the storming of Bastille by the common people to free up political prisoners.
Different historians have give different views on their historiography of the revolution regarding its nature, these are:
1. Le Febre : A social revolution. According to him the revolution involved 4 revolutions by different social classes, there were: Aristocratic, Bourgeoisie, Peasant, and Sans-Cullottes. while Aristocratic acted as the curtain raiser, Bourgeoisie toppled the government and set up a new constitution and declared Rts of man. Later on, simultaneously peasants in the countryside and Sans-Cullottes or the commoners to participated against monarchy. According to him, while each class has a distinctive character and together they represented a social revolution 2. Cobban; Taylor, etc : A political revolution According to them, it didnot transform the society as aristocracy was already dying and Bourgeoisie was not a major force during the revolution. Rather, it was a political revolution which represented struggle for control of the national government of France 3. George Rude : Popular Revolution He focussed on the role of commoners like : Women's March to Versailles ; Peasants protests across countryside, burning manors, records, etc. and the San-Cullotes revolution. 4. August Cochin : He focusses on the role of intelligensia, esp. the political philosophers and thinkers like Rousseau, Voltaire, Montesquieu, etc. How they presented a critique of the system and stirred the imagination of the people. 5. R.R. Palmer : Atlantic Revolution He considered french revolution to be part of larger atlantic revolution. According to him, it began in North America, came to Europe - Netherlands, Ireland, France, Switzerland, Italy, etc
Thus, various views put forth different dimensions of revolution as its true nature.
Hence, french revolution can be considered a mix of politico-social - economic - intellectual revolution.