'Harsha owes his greatness largely not to any real achievements but to the accounts of two famous men'. Elaborate. [20 Marks]
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
Harshavardhana, king of Kannauj and most of North India during the post-gupta era is remembered as the last great ruler of North India.
Achievements of Harsha that made him great 1. Political - large empire from Punjab to Bengal and from below Kashmir to Vindhyas - referred to as 'Lord of North' - subdued Nepal. 2. Religious - saivitic by faith who converted to Buddhism but tolerant to all - built charitable institution and spent his wealth generously for the needy. 3. Patron to learning - gave liberal grants to Nalanda - had large no. of scholars in his court.
But his greatness was amplified by two famous men: 1. Banabhatta 2. Hiuen Tsang
1. One reason was that the availability of material information on Harsha is not present for other rulers of the time. 2. Banabhatta: court historian and friend. - only source of fight with Gaud ruler => no clarifications - accused of bias in his portrayal of Harsha. - exaggerated many facts and personal qualities of Harsha. - was probably the ghost writer for Harsha's dramas - rarely put Harsha in bad light 3. Hiuen Tsang: Chinese pilgrim who spent quite some time in Harsha's court. - more trustworthy as he wrote it all after going back to china. - But his account is affected due to: - preconceived ideas of govt. - favor of Buddhism - mainly highlights positive aspects as Harsha was patron of Buddhism. - exaggerated accounts of: - size of Harsha's army - his military exploits - number of stupas created - no corporal punishment - light taxes, etc.
But, despite these exaggerations or biases their accounts present a vivid picture of the life of king Harsha.
And, it is not in doubt that Harsha was a great and competent ruler as after his death North India completely lost its vigour and disintegrated into fighting regional kingdoms.