Topper Copies

"The Hindus believe that there is no science like theirs." In the light of this statement, give a critical analysis of Al Beruni's account of Indian science.

Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023

Al Beruni through his book Kitab-u-hind gives an understanding of the Indian science during the 11th century.

Alberuni in his book gives an acount of various science known in India - Astronomy, Meteorology, Arithmetic, Chemistry, Mathematics, etc.

But at the same time, he is critical of it because: - He ascribes the downfall in Science of Indian to the growing arrogance of Indian Brahmins. - He calls them hypocrites for knowing the true reasons for natural phenomenon but still hiding behind superstitions. - He criticises the insular nature of the learned class - Moreover he is critical of the alchemy (Rasayana) which he equates to witchcraft.

But beyond the criticism, he is also appreciative of: 1. Indian advances in astronomy eg Indians knew cause behind eclipses or planetary motion. 2. He compares greek astronomy to Indian astronomy. 3. He mentions indian order of numbers, zero and even quotes Brahmagupta. 4. He appreciates the construction of ponds and holly bathing sites.

Thus, he concludes with - Indians are good mathematicians and astrologers and excellent philosophers but he puts his knowledge above them.