Give various estimates of population of Mughal India given by historians.
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
Historians world over are divided over the actual population estimate of Mughal India. Initially 100 mn. was accepted but overtime different historians have tried to fine tune and revise this estimate. Since no census was ever done in the empire, we can only look through ancillary data from texts like - Ain-i-Akbari.
Morland's estimation - made the 1st such attempt. - used the revenue data (measured) for north and military strength in south (arbitrary ratio 1:30) - he gave 60 mn. for Akbar's empire.
Various objections were cited on this, such as: 1. measurement wasn't complete and included not just cultivable area. 2. arbitrary 1:30 (army : civilian) ratio was compared to pre WW I modern states.
In this context, other historians have presented their estimates:
Kingsley Davis He increased moreland's whole India estimate from 100 to 125 mn. by increasing weight to outside areas. He didn't really address the major flaws mentioned in Moreland's estimates.
Ashok Desai - tried to use different data i.e. using purchasing power of urban wages with the prices given in Ain-i-Akbari.
Shireen Moosvi - used similar method to Moreland but improved somewhat by assuming larger landholding in 1600. - ∴ she arrived at 100 mn. for Akbar's Empire and 140-150 mn for whole of India.
Despite all their attempts, these still remain as 'estimates' due to paucity of any strong contemporary data.