Evaluate the account of Fa Hien as a source of history of Ancient India. How his account can be compared with the account of Hiuen Tsang? [15 Marks]
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
Fa hein was a Chinese buddhist pilgrim who visited India in the 4th Century CE in search of buddhist texts.
During his stay he visited many buddhist sites, lived in monasteries and ultimately after going back wrote an account of his journey called - " A record of Buddhist Kingdoms"
He gave an account of various aspects of ancient Indian life, such as:
Social
India is a peaceful country; low crime rate; no need of passports to travel. Peoples are vegetarian and don't eat onion. He talks of untouchables as consumers of meat & how Shudras lived outside the town & used a drum when entering.
Religious
Buddhism was flourishing but theistic hinduism was the major religion. He didn't mention jainism, though he does mention religious harmony.
Economic
He says the kingdom was prosperous, land as main form of revenue and agriculture based economy primarily.
Political
He didnot mention the name of the king but indirectly implies he was benevolent. He visited the palace of Ashoka.
Comparison to Hiuen Tsang
Hiuen Tsang, another buddhist pilgrim, also provided an account of his travel. - Fa hein's account lacks information and details about social, economic and political life that Hiuen Tsang mentioned (like he mentions dresses, festivals, food types, etc). - Fa hein and Hiuen Tsang both presented an idealised picture of India. - Hiuen Tsang also described various sects and the complete religious picture of the country. - Fa-hein was mostly focused on buddhist monastries and his studies and not on the ordinary life. - Some places that they both visited had chaged drastically in 300 years like Patliputra to Hiuen Tsang was not a main city anymore.
Thus, both Pilgrims presented a picture of india and are important sources of our history.