Topper Copies

Did ancient India have any interest in preserving the memory of the past? Critically Discuss. [15 Marks]

Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023

Many scholars like V.A Smith and H.H. Wilson have described Indian society as a static society with no concept of time but cyclical time and thus registered no historical change. This was mentioned in comparison to Greek and Chinese histories of the time.

But, historian Romila Thapar presents a contrarian view by providing a distinction between Embedded and Externalised history writing. According to her, in lineage based societies, like those in India, history writing is 'not event' and needs to be pieced out from the sources.

At the same time, many writings of ancient India present a conscious effort to preserve the memory of the past, these are : 1. In later vedic era there were dana-stutis, akhyans, narasamsi, etc which represented narrative incidents. 2. Further, the tradition of Itihas-Purana refers to genealogies of kings, rishis and many. 3. Epics like Ramayana and Mahabharata too contain pieces of historical information. 4. Similarly, there existed classes like Bards (in Sangam) and Sutas and Magadhas (in North) who were involved in the job of writing about kings and their family and court happenings. 5. Similarly Royal biographies and royal inscriptions of Ashoka, Kharvel and Harsha refer to their exploits. While these were eulogistic in nature they still represent historical information. 6. There have also been evidences of kings maintaining Royal archives to preserve official records as mentioned by Alberuni and Hiuen Tsang, though none survived.

Thus it would be safe to say that Indians did have an interest in preserving the memory of the past, the differences occur on the idea of history differs from age to age and intellectuals of every age decide what aspects they consider important.