Topper Copies

"Dyarchy (1919) could not satisfy the national sentiments of the Indians." Discuss.

Simran, AIR 66, 2024

Dyarchy referred to the division of Reserved transferred subjects among central and state level of government by Montague - Chelmsford Reforms of 1919.

Dyarchy could not satisfy national sentiments

1. Indians wanted greater share in power which was not addressed by dyarchy. - Final power of decision resided with governor. 2. Dyarchy created confusion in administration. - Agriculture was transferred subject but irrigation was reserved, despite being inherently connected. 3. Major areas of power were kept under reserved category. - (Ex) Finance, law and order, irrigation,etc. 4. The Governor and his executive council which decided on 'Reserved' subjects was not responsible to the legislature. 5. Overall, a state of confusion was created in administration which obstructed functioning of various departments.

Dyarchy as a system was scrapped by recommendation of Simon Commission. In Government of India Act 1935, provincial dyarchy ended while central dyarchy was introduced.