What were the policies and programmes of the early nationalists (moderates)? Were they able to fulfil the aspirations of the people?
Simran, AIR 66, 2024
The early nationalists constituted moderate leaders such as Dadabhai Naoroji, Pherozshah Mehta, S.N. Banerjee, W.C. Banerjee, etc. They relied on softer outlook towards British rule.
Policies and programmes of early nationalists
1. Economic Policies - Moderate gave the theory of drainage of Indian wealth by British. - Dadabhai Naoroji displayed the exploitative nature of British rule and demanded economic reforms. - Moderates called for extension of Permanent Settlement and removal of salt tax and income tax. - They also campaigned against home charges. 2. Administrative policies
3. Military reforms - Reduction of British military expenditure. - Adequate payment to Indian soldiers. 4. Political reforms - Extension of non-official members in the council. - Members be given the authority to question and discuss budget. - Efforts be made to increase participation of Indians in administration
Moderates used the tools of 'prayer, petition, protest' to present their demands. However, they maintained firm belief in British providential mission.
Moderates - able to fulfil people's aspiration
Moderates succeeded in - Providing a national platform (of Congress) to voice indigenous grievances. - They destroyed the paternalistic impression of British rule through drainage theory. - They brought British attention to diverse demands of Indians.
However, Modrates failed
- British made no changes in their military policies. - Age of appearing in civil services exam was further reduced. - Fowler Commission artificially inflated rupee - sterling ratio. - Income Tax was removed but was re-imposed. - Political reforms through Council of India Act 1892 was too meagre with no right to discuss budget.
The shortcomings of moderates gave space to the rise of extremist factions. Yet, the groundwork done by moderates in alleviating status of Indian National Congress shall not be undermined.