"The partition of India was neither inevitable nor the product of sheer chance. It was not the fulfilment of destiny or the logical outcome of the two nation theory; nor was it simply an accident that was produced by a single wrong decision or failure of judgement. The partition of India was the product of complex processes and was the outcome of several factors." In the light of the given statement, discuss various factors responsible for the partition of India.
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
15th August, 1947, India got its long awaited tryst with destiny as we gained Independence from colonial rule, but at the same time, we also experienced the sheer horror that was the partition of India into Pakistan and India.
The above statement discusses how partition wasn't inevitable as claimed by Jinnah, nor was it fulfilment of some destiny or failure of judgement as claimed by some others. It was rather a product of several factors, detailed below.
1. Communal policy of British Empire since late 19th Century and its real introduction with the Separate Electorates. 2. This was further visible in their appeasement of Muslim league in - Shimla Conference, Cripps mission, Interim Government, etc. 3. New-communalism (rose) from 1936-37 onwards with the idea of - " Religion in danger" and the only solution is separate state. 4. This policy gave Muslim league great victory in the 1945-46 elections & strengthened their negotiating forum. 5. 'Direct Action Day' strategy of "Lad kar lege Pakistan" → giving birth to large scale violence. 6. Failure of talks between league and Congress leaders. eg → Desai-Liaqat, Rajgopalachari Formula, etc. 7. Longterm failure of INC to assimilate muslims into the national movement (Acc. to Bipin Chandra) 8. Formation of Interim government and league involved without giving up direct action day. 9. Failure of London talks by Atlee. 10. Finally acceptance of partition as foregone conclusion given the necessity of the situation.
Thus, Partition of India was a result of long term factors that accumulated over time to create a situation of inevitability by 1946-47 as the league got too powerful and communal riots increased while the British acquired a sense of urgency to leave India and leaving its problems to Indians.
Regardless of factors, it remains a dark day for both countries and on the eve of 75th Independence day, it begs to be remembered.