Topper Copies

"To characterize the Quit India Movement as 'Spontaneous Revolution' or as the culmination of Gandhian Satyagraha movements would be partial interpretation". Elucidate.

Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023

On 8th Aug 1942 - AICC in Bombay adopted the Quit India resolution, to begin the movement under Gandhiji.

On 9th Aug. 1942, Britishers arrested all top ranking members of congress, essentially leaving the movement 'leaderless'.

This situation, and this move resulted in protests and fury all over the country and was violent and 'massy' in social character and base. Viceroy and his ilk characterised this as the 'Spontaneous revolution' due to no plan or leader.

But, the revolution wasn't spontaneous as : 1. Masses over last two decades had been trained by the leaders of congress and they knew their role. 2. The plan was known to lower level members of congress who acted on it. 3. Leaders like Sucheta Kriplani, Aruna Asaf Ali, Usha Mehta, Ram manohar Lohia, led the movement from front & hiding underground. 4. The actions of peasants, students, etc. were well within the mandate of 'do or die' given by Gandhiji. [?]

Further, it can't be said to be the culmination of Gandhian satyagraha as : 1. tenets of non-violence and peaceful protesting were frequently violated. 2. Underground, sabotage activities were never part of gandhian Satyagraha. 3. Parallel governments that emerged, while talked of following Gandhian ideals, were far from his ideas as he never gave a conclusive way of capturing power.

But, at the same time, Gandhi himself had asked people to decide on their own if they wanted to follow non-violence and he refused to condemn the violence when asked by British authorities.

Thus, the revolution of August of 1942, was spontaneous, but planned, Gandhian in phases but non-gandhian in others. It won't be wrong to say then that - " Gandhi was the undisputed leader of the movement but he had little command over it. "