"The Royal Indian Navy Revolt was seen as an event which marked the end of the British rule almost as finally as Independence Day." Critically examine.
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
In the summer of 1945-46, the British Indian navy ratings at HMS Talwar in Bombay, went on a strike to protest against : bad food, racial discrimination and INA trials. Other ratings too joined in and soon the protest developed a national character.
The event marked the end of British rule as : (after 1857) 1. For the first time, the institution of military was also showing its dissatisfaction. 2. [?] Cabinet Mission was immediately sent off to the country. 3. Army Commander when asked the mood of the soldiers, replied by asking for clemency to INA prisoners.
But at the same time, there are certain limitations to the view that RIN revolt had direct impact as : 1. these upsurges were short-lived. 2. only a few sections of society participated (that too in urban areas) 3. Army was called in and the troops fired on people and the ratings in Karachi & in Bombay they rounded them up.
Thus, it can be argued that despite the upsurges, British were willing & able to crush them - And the real reason to transfer power was more a result of realisation of erosion of their legitimacy over many years of struggle.