Q.8 (c) Give various references to the republics (gana-sanghas) in ancient Indian sources and factors for their rise and decline? Were they democratic in nature? [20 Marks]
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
Gana Sanghas or Republics (as they were called by Nationalist historians) refers to the tribo-political organisations that existed parallel to the monarchy of the Mahajanpada era, chief among them being Vajji and Malla.
References to Gana-Sanghas 1. Anguttara Nikaya references all 16 Mahajanpadas and specifics Vajjis and Mallas as Saghas 2. Greek historians of Alexander' conquest references republic city states on North-west 3. Arthashastra mentions several [?] such as Licchavikas, Madras, etc 4. Coins of Yaudheyas and Malavas point to their non-monarchical polity 5. Megasthenes in his Indica too references democratic government in some cities with no kings
Factors in their rise 1. reaction against vedic pattern of life -> (eg) ritualistic, sacrificial and segmented 2. against hereditary kingship -> old vedic tribals joined forces 3. based on the old tribal idea of equality 4. socio-economic situation -> wherein members demanded right to collect taxes and share of produce 5. Some of them may have either -> broken away from monarchies or subverted existing monarchical rule
Causes of their declin 1. Monarchies -> stronger zeal for empire - standing armies - single head 2. Internal quarrels and dissatisfaction - used by Ajatshatru's minister and Arthashastra also preaches 3. concentration of power in few hands, who refused to hand it over 4. Most of them were small in size, in comparison to Avanti or Magadha 5. Caste arrogance and lack of real democracy. => rather a form of oligarchy which couldn't be contained
Democratic nature of Republics - While it was not a rule by single ruler, the rulers were not elected - Gana parishad had supreme authority in administration, it was many a times one-upped by strong clans - women were not included in assemblies and nor were Lower castes - while meeting at Santhagaras had voting to make decisions
Thus, despite having some features of democratic government, the Gana-Sanghas could at best be called Oligarchies and not democracies.