'India is uniquely positioned on the world map for its rich culture.' In this context discuss the role of culture, diaspora, and democracy as instruments of India's soft power diplomacy. To what extent India has been able to position itself as a 'smart power'?
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
India, being a multi-cultural and diverse nation, has enormous soft power potential, which is magnified by Indian values of peace, peaceful co-existence, democracy, etc.
Role of culture in diplomacy 1. Highlight the benefit of Indian values, to develop attraction towards India (eg: International Yoga Day; yoga in schools during the Tigray war in Ethiopia) 2. Cuisine: diverse cuisine gradually gaining acceptance globally (eg: curries in Australia) 3. Role of ICCR (Indian Council of Cultural Relations): organizing cultural exchanges, workshops, etc 4. Art, literature and movies, etc (eg: popularity of the work of Tagore) 5. Future potential: education (internationalization), digital media, etc
Role of diaspora 1. NRIs as "bridge builders" in advancing India's interests (eg: role in the Indo-USA nuclear deal) 2. "Diaspora diplomacy" (eg: the Samosa Caucus in the USA Congress) 3. Role in tech transfer, funding, etc (eg: 9/10 Indian startups receive funding from Silicon Valley) 4. NRIs providing niche services in foreign nations (eg: Raika camel rearing community from Rajasthan in the Middle East)
Role of democracy Historically, democracy has not played a major role in global diplomacy. However, since the end of the Cold War, it has increasingly featured in foreign policy discussions, and further, with the rise of USA-China tensions, it is in the news further.
India's values as the "mother of democracy" and commitment to a "free and open Indo-Pacific" will play a key role in foreign policy in years to come: - as a differentiator from China - as a nation committed to the principle of CBDR (Common but Differentiated Responsibility) — equity in IR
India as a smart power — has it been successful?
| Yes | No | |---|---| | Leveraging culture, such as yoga | Delivery deficit | | Leveraging diaspora to advance interests | Outreach is very less, as compared to China's Confucius network or France's Alliance Française, etc | | Consistent messaging on peace: "not an era of war" | India not in the top 30 in the Portland Soft Power Index | | Voice of the Global South | Only 126 embassies |
Way forward: build on culture and diaspora; expand presence via embassies and ICCR; ensure there is no delivery deficit