"The 16th century of Medieval India should be regarded as the period of Indian Renaissance." Critically examine. [20 Marks]
Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023
The presence of powerful empires like Vijayanagar, Mughals as well as grass-root Bhakti movement in the 16th century lead to tectonic shifts in Indian culture leading to some terming it as renaissance.
Indian renaissance in 16th century 1. Cultural rebirth under Vijayanagar empire - King Krishna Deva Raya (KDR) patronized 8 elite poets - Ashta-diggajas including Tenali Rama - KDR himself was proficient in Telugu, Kannada, Tamil, Sanskrit and wrote books like Amuktamalyada, Jambavati Kalyanam. - KDR also patronized temple building (Eg.) Virupaksha temple, Vitalhadra temple etc. - Vijayanagar temple paintings also reached Zenith under K.D.R 2. Renaissance under Mughals - Akbar started painting in Mughal Court by opening Tasvir Khana. - Construction of huge monuments like- Fatehpur Sikri, Humayun's Tomb, Agra fort etc. - Impetus to poetry and literature in Mughal Court. (Eg.) Khan-i-khana was a great poet. - Music - Tansen popularized Dhrupad Singing in Mughal Court and invented new musical instruments and ragas. (Eg.) Raga deepak, Miyan ki Malhar. - Technological development - Akbar invented a cartmill, gun cleaning machine, Simultaneous Cannons and he also patronized inventors like Mir Fatullah Shirazi. 3. Renaissance by Bhakti - Upward religious social movement of lowers castes. - Nirguna saints like Kabir questioned orthodoxy and temple centric worshipping - Development of Bhakti literature: Kabir's Bijak, Guru Nanak's hymns in Adi granth, Jnandev Abhangas in Marathi and Mirabai's Songs.
Limitations of Indian renaissance 1. Heavy external influence - from Persia under Mughals. 2. Inadequate participation of people from all sections especially lower castes. 3. Unable to counter religious orthodoxy - held sway over public minds. 4. Limited proliferation of scientific ideals as seen in Europe.
Thus 16th century saw the resurgence of culture in India along with its own limitations.