Topper Copies

"The rise of the Harappan Civilization was not due to any outside influence or a sudden act but it was a result of gradual evolution." Comment. [15 Marks]

Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023

Although the evidence of mature Harappan civilization by 2600 BC is well established, historians are divided on the nature of its origin and evolution.

Causes of rise of Harappan Civilization 1. Diffusionist Theory - As per E.J.H Mackay, harappa was established because of outside influence of Mesopotamia. - As per him, people of Sumer migrated to harappan towns thus founding new cities. - R.E.M wheeler argues for diffusion of ideas and not people behind Harappan rise. 2. Limitations of diffusionist theory - Difference in script. - Different city layout, art and craft. 3. Indigenous origin - As per Amalananda Ghosh, harappan civilization gradually evolved from early farming communities in Mehrgarh in 7000BC. - M.R. Mughal observed similarity in housing, raw material between pre and mature urban phases. - As per him, harappan civilization evolved due to agricultural surplus, art and craft specialization, advanced script and long distance trade with Mesopotamia. - Shireen Ratnagar contends the role of Lapis lazuli trade behind growth and decline of harappan civilization.

Thus, harappan civilization clearly has indigenous local underpinnings and influence of outside events has been exaggerated.