Topper Copies

Examine the literary sources for reconstruction of Ancient Indian History along with its limitations. [15 Marks]

Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023

Literary sources are a major source of ancient historical reconstruction albeit with limitations.

Advantages of literary sources 1. Helps in tracking socio-religious customs of ancient time. Eg Levirate in ancient India. 2. Provides an idealistic view point of the writer. Eg. Dharmashastra => ideal social behaviors. 3. Development and evolution of religions. Eg. Mahayanism from Lotus Sutra 4. Reconstruction of everyday life of a common man. Eg. Life of a nagarak in Kamasutra. 5. Development and evolution of language and script through texts. Eg. Ornate poetry during gupta age.

Limitations 1. Age of creation unknown - texts may be older than when 1st written. Eg. Rig Veda as old as 6000 BCE. 2. Multiplicity of authors each adding their own story. Eg. Multiple authors of Mahabharat 3. Periodic addition and modification over the ages → true text completely changed. 4. Generally written by upper classes – neglect of lower classes like dalits, women. 5. Mixing of myths with facts, event. Also exaggeration of events. 6. Lack of correlation with archaeology. Eg. Archaeological evidence of ancient mahajanapad is scant.

Thus, careful analysis of literary sources, keeping in mind these limitations is required.