"Germany is to be a great extent held responsible for causing both the first and the second World Wars." Critically discuss.
Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023
Both the world wars were caused due to the complex geopolitical situation in Europe and Germany had a major part to play in it.
Germany's responsibility
1. World War I (WWI) - Rapid militarization, naval expansion by Germany in early 20th century led to arms race. - Economic competition with Britain soured the international atmosphere E.g. Germany became 2nd largest steel producer in 20th century. - Bismark blood and iron policy - Capture of Alscae, Lorraine from France led to Franco-German Hostility. - formation of Covert Alliances - like Triple alliance of Germany, Austro-Hungary and Italy. - Unconditional support to Austria against Serbia and declaration of War upon Russia, Britain and France. - Military mobalization - under Schlieffen plan led to start of WWI. 2. World War II (WWII) - Violating Versailles Treaty - by rapid re-armament, introducing Conscription etc. - Militarization of Rhine as opposed to Versailles treaty. - Anschluss with Austria by removing democratic government. - Withdrawal from League of Nations (1933) and disarmament conference by Hitler - formation of Rome-Berlin Axis and anti-Comintern pact - Destruction of Czechoslovakia - by demanding sudetanland. - Invasion of Poland (1939) and alliance with USSR (Molotov-Ribbentrop pact).
However, other factors also led to World Wars.
other factors
1. formation of Triple Entente - by UK to encircle Germany. during WW1 2. Russian support to Serbia during WWI also led to war. 3. Unfair harsh Versailles treaty imposed on Germany. 4. The great depression 1929 - led to rise of Nazi party. 5. Appeasement politics - As per A.J.P Taylor, appeasement by UK led to WWII. 6. Guilt of Japan, Italy in WWII.
Thus, blaming Germany entirely for World Wars would be reductionist approach.