Assess the role of British imperial power in complicating the process of transfer of power during the 1940s. [20 marks]
Simran, AIR 66, 2024
The decade of 1940s was full of discussions and delibrations on extent and nature of power transfer to Indian colony by British.
Role of British in complicating the process of transfer of power
1. Refusal to accede to Indian demands When Indians were demanding Dominion Status, British refused to it. But when Indians extended their demands to full independence, British offered dominion status. 2. Lack of Indian representation Most of initiatives of British did not feature Indian involvment. (Ex) Cripps Mission, Cabinet Mission. 3. Ambiguity on formation of Pakistan Ex) In August offer and Cripps Mission there was no concession for Pakistan formation. But breakdown of Shimla Conference gave leeway to demand for Pakistan 4. Lack of clarity of Cabinet proposal The distribution of provinces in three groups and subsequent clause to change groupings was not made clear. - While Congress assumed that provinces could change groups, Muslim League assumed the opposite. 5. Actual transfer of power British kept on changing the date of power transfer as per their convenience. Ex) Earlier date of June 1948 was rushed to August 1947. 6. Abrupt end of British rule The attitude of evading responsibility of ensuing partition made British abruptly exit India. - There was no clarity around partition among masses. - The line of partition was drawn by Radcliff who never visited India. - British left Indian subcontinent unstable and divided.
While the internal political struggle between Congress and Muslim League had already complicated the talks around power transfer, British had further contributed to these complications.