Q.4 (b) Do you agree that ecological factors influenced the flow and ebb of the Harappan Civilization? Comment. [15 Marks]
Udit Kadian, AIR 375, 2023
Harappan Civilisation which emerged in its mature phase by 2450 BCE, had disappeared by 1750 BCE. This decline has given rise to various theories, with ecological factors being one such :
1. ecological degradation by Fairservis
He is of the belief that as Harappan civilisation grew, its population (human and cattle) grew to such an extent that the region and its hinterland failed to support this growth.
They were responsible for scouring off the region of all its resources and with this scarcity of resources - more floods and droughts occured.
This further affected the subsistence base, which was now unable to sustain its villages much less the urban population.
This resulted in their eastward and south ward migration as seen from archaeological evidences..
2. Monsoon Link Theory of 2012 by R. Adhikari & L. Giosan
Accordly to this, climate change was responsible for their decline.
The weakning of monsoon in the region around 1700 BCE resulted in disappearence of Saraswati and decline of civilisation.
While some question marks have been raised on the arguments presented above as: 1. enduring fertility of soils of Indian subcontinent till today dis prom soil exhaustio 2. Existence of strong Indus river till today
But despite these, based on latest research and scientific data, the idea that ecological degradation combined by one-off floods, earthquakes and river shiftings together must have brought about the ebb of Harappan Civilisation.