'Satisfactory and timely redressal of grievances is the cornerstone of "minimum government, maximum governance."' In this context discuss the challenges associated with current grievance redress mechanisms and suggest measures to strengthen the process.
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
It is said that "justice delayed is justice denied."
The World Bank has repeatedly pointed out how lack of resolution of grievances in India is a key factor for poor ease of doing business in India (eg: it takes 120 days to resolve commercial grievances in Singapore v/s 1400+ days in India).
Current grievance redressal mechanisms and their challenges
Judiciary (subordinate courts → High Court → Supreme Court) - ~5 cr pending cases - ~4 years to resolve civil cases, ~5 years to resolve criminal cases - Adversarial - Expensive: litigation unaffordable for the poor - Causes mental stress and agony
ADR (Alternate Dispute Resolution: arbitration, conciliation, mediation, etc) 1. Often, the decision of ADR is challenged in courts — adds to delay 2. Lack of awareness amongst citizens 3. Lack of trained personnel for arbitration/mediation — people trust ADR less
Tribunals (eg: CAT, NGT, NCLT, etc) 1. Understaffed (eg: vacancies in NCLT) 2. Pendency in tribunals (eg: ~1 lakh pending cases in NCLT, ~9 lakh cr worth of tax disputes before various tax authorities like ITAT, appellate tribunal, etc) 3. "Tribunalization of justice" 4. Concern about independence of members
Inbuilt grievance redressal in govt schemes (eg: district and state level food commissions to complain about grievances related to NFSA) 1. Lack of awareness amongst beneficiaries 2. Red tapism, bureaucratic inertia
Grievance redressal — statutory modes (eg: ICC and LCC under the POSH Act) 1. Not implemented in letter and spirit 2. Scope restricted; jurisdiction restricted (eg: ICC is not applicable to the unorganized sector)
Way forward 1. Judiciary: fill vacancies (~18,000/~23,000 judges at subordinate courts); use technology (eg: interoperable criminal justice system, National Judicial Data Grid, e-Courts Mission, etc); separate staff for judicial administration (eg: as in the USA, Canada, UK, etc) 2. ADR: create awareness; trained professionals; popularize and regularize Lok Adalats (eg: in 2022, Lok Adalats resolved 1 crore cases in 1 day — a world record) 3. Tribunals: National Tribunal Commission, as recommended in the L. Chandra Kumar case 4. Citizens Charter to improve executive grievance redressal (eg: Model Panchayat Charter)