Topper Copies

Discuss the crucial role played by the National Commission of Women in shaping the discourse on gender-sensitive laws in India. To what extent the elevation of the National Commission for Women to a constitutional body would reinforce its authority?

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

The National Commission of Women (NCW) was set up by the NCW Act 1990 (in 1992), i.e. it is a statutory body.

Crucial role played by NCW in shaping the discourse on gender-sensitive laws in India 1. Regular and periodic review/inspection of laws (eg: IPC 1860, PCPNDT 1994, Dowry Prohibition 1961, etc) — based on efforts and review by the NCW, in the recently introduced Bharatiya Nyaya Samhita (IPC revamp), "crimes against women" is the first chapter 2. Evidence-based analysis of laws, based on regular inspection of jails, custodial homes and psychiatric institutions 3. Understanding how laws work on the ground level — the NCW looks into ~15,000 cases annually 4. Learning from shared experience: the NCW works with civil society, etc, in pursuit of its goals 5. Highlighting constraints in the criminal justice system: the NCW can act as a litigant in the cases it pursues, which gives it a first-hand view of the functioning of the criminal justice system, but leads to delay in women getting justice (eg: PCPNDT Act 1994) 6. Awareness about laws 7. Highlight non-compliance of laws (eg: NCW has highlighted that Local Complaint Committees, LCCs, are not constituted under the POSH Act 2013)

Elevation of NCW to a constitutional body would help in the following ways 1. Give it greater say in investigations (eg: NCSC, NCST, NCBC, etc) 2. Give it power to determine its own procedure (eg: NCSC, NCST, NCBC, etc) 3. Will allow the NCW to not only investigate specific cases, but also overall "safeguards" 4. Widen the ambit of gender-responsive governance (eg: to the unorganized sector, etc)

However, there are several disadvantages of constitutional status. 1. NCSC, NCST and NCBC are not allowed to coordinate with NGOs, civil society, etc — if the NCW gets constitutional status, this ability to coordinate may go away 2. Similarly, the aforementioned bodies are not allowed to take suo motu cases or do suo motu research — if the NCW becomes a constitutional body, these powers may also go away

I.e. overall operational flexibility will reduce.

Thus, the decision to convert the NCW to a constitutional body has to be taken keeping in mind the aforementioned pros and cons.