"The Non-cooperation Movement had both strong and weak aspects." Discuss with proper examples.
Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023
The Non-Cooperation Movement (NCM) 1920-22 was the 1st Gandhian pan-India movement aimed at securing 'Swaraj' for the people of India.
Strong aspect of NCM
1. Emergence of new concept of Satyagraha and Non-violence advocated by Gandhi. 2. Mass participation - Students left schools, universities, women participated in large numbers for picketing of shops. 3. Successful economic boycott of British import of foreign textile fell by half. 4. Massive Muslim mobalization due to Khilafat andolan and relative hindu-muslim unity was seen. 5. Impetus to indigenization - Indian universities, courts were set up to boycott colonial institutions. Eg. Kashi Vidyapeeth in 1920. 6. New concept of nationalism - as opposed to passive loyalist early moderates emerged. ↳ NCM demanded 'Swaraj' or self rule as opposed to indigenization of colonial state.
Weak aspect of NCM
1. Encouraged communalization of politics - by linking Khilafat Islamic issue with Indian movement. Eg Ali Brothers frequently used religious rhetoric. 2. Backward looking movement - aiming for restoration of feudal, Monarchical ottoman empire in Turkey. 3. Lack of participation of peasants and rural workers in villages. 4. Social polarization and tensions - people were forced to follow NCM by threat of economic boycott at many places. 5. Movement loosing steam - many people rejoined universities, courts due to lack of alternatives. 6. Khadi was very expensive for poor - cannot sustain for long. 7. Severe British repression including capital punishment 8. Abrupt withdrawl and disillusionment of nationalist after Chauri - Chaura incident. 9. Instances of violence - like Moplah rebellion -> Shahid amin said people misrepresented gandhi's message.
Despite its weakness, NCM was a pivotal movement in the evolution of Indian freedom struggle.