Topper Copies

'The declining role of Parliament undermines the fundamental principle of separation of powers, as it diminishes the legislature's ability to serve as a check on the executive branch and ensure a balanced exercise of power.' Discuss.

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

According to C. Rajagopalachari: "Parliament is governance by discussion, not governance by disruption."

| Declining role of Parliament | How it undermines the legislature | |---|---| | 1. Frequent disruptions (eg: placards display, storming the well, etc) | Discussions can't take place → less opportunity to question the executive | | 2. Less than 40-45% of bills referred to parliamentary committees since 2004 | Incomplete scrutiny of legislations → executive has to do the function of the legislature → separation of powers undermined → frequent amendments needed (eg: 6 amendments to the IBC in 7 years) | | 3. Number of sitting days declined from ~120 to ~60 | Legislators can't raise issues concerning citizens → violation of democratic ethos | | 4. Average discussion length reduced to ~2 hours per bill in the Lok Sabha and ~2 hours in the Rajya Sabha | Poor scrutiny of laws → protests outside parliament (eg: farm law bills/acts, now repealed) | | 5. Whip and anti-defection law: private members of the ruling party bound by whip | Legislature not able to hold executive accountable → freedom of speech compromised | | 6. Criminalization of politics: ~45% criminals in the 17th Lok Sabha | Criminals not able to hold executive accountable | | 7. Poor private member bills: discussed only 4 times in the 17th Lok Sabha | Less opportunity for the legislature to represent views before the executive | | 8. Committee on petitions meets only periodically | Parliament unable to address petitions by ordinary citizens | | 9. Less attendance | Faith of the public in the institution reduces | | 10. Low women representation | Poor understanding of women's issues |

Thus, the declining role of parliament has compromised not only the separation of powers (part of the basic structure), but also the faith for the institution amongst citizens.

Way forward 1. 120-day sitting, as recommended by the NCRWC 2. Compulsory referral of bills to parliamentary committees, who should act on them in a time-bound manner (eg: 3 months) 3. Weekly discussion of private member bills 4. Utilization of the 30-minute/2-hour discussion

These steps will make "parliament" "governance by discussion."