Topper Copies

"The hypothesis that there was urban decay during c. 300-600 CE, can be questioned on several grounds." Elaborate. [15 Marks]

P Aswin, AIR 567, 2025

Historians like R.S sharma ad DD Kashambi has mentioned the period between 300-600CE of Indian history as a stary Urban decay and feudalism era .

Reasons in support of Urban decay 1. The habitation level thinned out in may of the cites during this period (eg) Pataliputra 2 Hastinapura . 2. The trade with west europeans & South east nations declines 3. The Quality of coins got poor and debasement of gold coins were seen .. 4. Reuse of bricks in structures 5. Literary Sources like Brihasamhita rations absent the decline in crafts 6. Change in meaning of terms like, earlier shreshthi meant guild, but later a clan . 7. Increase of Land grants to brahmans led to increase of feudalism and closed gated societies & villages -

But other historians like B.D Chattopadaya and Herman Kulke interpret this period as transition of society and not necessary urban decay.

Questions of this hypothesis 1. Increase of new cities in place of old cities was seen like rise of Kancay, Mathura, Kanchipuram etc 2. New crafts. and increase in artistic innovations could be observed with the increased terms in Amarakosha. 3. Literary text like Kalidasa raghuvansha describes about the mansions of Ujjain. 4. Kamasutra even describes about the lives of people of cities and their entertained activities. 5. John S. dayal describes the delaserent of gold coins could mean increased activities of economic exchange & need of coins. 6. Sabbmeyalu describes the land donation never exceeded 20 -/. of total empire land and many of them were donated to increase the productivity of barren land. 7. Trade got decentralised and many new centres of trade emerged in place of old long distance trade as per chandlari.

Thus the period inspite of showing some decolonisation gave rise to local kingdoms and centres of new activities.