Topper Copies

"The overriding powers of the Governor diluted the spirit of autonomy brought by the Government of India Act of 1935 by replacing diarchy with provincial autonomy." Elucidate.

Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023

The Government of India Act 1935, despite after 3-round table conference, was not able to satisfy the nationalist.

Provincial autonomy

1. Abolished provincial dyarchy of 1919 act 2. Provinces derived power from Crown 3. federal power division into 3 list= Central, provincial and Concurrent. 4. Financial autonomy to provinces to borrow money on their own. 5. Responsible government - ministers accountable to legislature.

Dilution of automony

1. Governor not responsible to legislature. 2. Governor having veto powers to reject any bill. 3. Special powers of governor - encroach on autonomy. 4. Emergency provisions - governor to dismiss government and carry on governance indefinitely.

Owning to these limitations, J.L. Nehru termed the GoI Act 1935 as "all breaks and no engine".