Topper Copies

Discuss the role of the Supreme Court of India in strengthening the hands of the Election Commission in the discharge of its constitutional responsibility of conducting free and fair elections in the country.

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

Supreme Court, recently in the Anoop Baranwal case (2023), gave guidelines for the selection of the CEC and ECs, to uphold the independence of the ECI.

In this context, the SC has historically played a significant role in strengthening the Election Commission of India.

1. Appointment of the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and other Election Commissioners (ECs) - Anoop Baranwal case → appointment to be by a committee of the PM, Chief Justice, and Leader of Opposition (Lok Sabha) 2. Related to the right of citizens to know 1. ADR v/s Union of India (2002): every candidate must disclose criminal cases and personal assets — if he/she doesn't, the Election Commission may disqualify them 2. Public Interest Foundation v/s Union of India (2019): SC ordered parties to prominently publish criminal cases against contestants, and asked the ECI to create a framework to disseminate info about the criminals as much as possible 3. Related to criminalization 1. Lily Thomas case (2013): struck down Section 8(4) of RPA 1951, which gave disqualified criminals a right to appeal and get their disqualification suspended 2. Public Interest Foundation case (2014): trials of criminal politicians to be finished in 1 year 4. Related to powers of the Returning Officer - Resurgence India case (2013): power to reject a nomination if incomplete 5. Power related to citizens voting - PUCL vs Union of India case (2013): NOTA - VVPATs: for verification 6. Related to freebies - "Freebies distort voters' choice" — S. Balaji case directed the ECI to look into the issue, and the ECI added a new point in the Model Code of Conduct 7. Related to election expenditure - Ashok Chavan case: power to the ECI to scrutinize expenditure by candidates, and disqualify them if RPA 1951 is not followed 8. Related to voter mobilisation - Abhiram Singh case: soliciting votes on grounds of caste/religion is illegal under Section 123 — the ECI must disqualify such candidates

Thus, SC judgements have made significant additions to ECI powers.

Way forward: inner-party democracy and transparency in funding → power to deregister parties