Q.3 (c) "By granting Muslims separate electorates the Imperial power institutionalized their division from other Indians." Comment.
Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023
Separate electorates were granted to muslims for the 1st time in Morley Minto reforms 1909.
Features of separate electorate
1. Electorates from where only muslims can contest and vote 2. Representation in excess of population 3. Low qualification criteria than others
Impact
1. It led to communalization of politics 2. By linking politics and religion, it yielded space to communal leaders. 3. It became the basis of all future demands of Muslim league including partition and Pakistan. 4. It started similar demands from other sections such as christians, sikhs, dalits. 5. It gave rise to reactionary communal hindu politics which opposed Muslim League. (Eg.) Hindu Mahasabha formed in 1915.
Counter arguments
1. Despite communal electorate large muslim participation observed in Khilafat andolan. 2. Congress maintained its secular character and had many muslim leaders.
However, Communal separate electorate was instrumental in increasing communal-ization of society and ultimately culminated in partition.