Topper Copies

Q.3 (a) "Why did the British finally quit India on 15th August 1947? The imperialist answer is that independence was simply the fulfilment of British self-appointed mission to assist the Indian people to self-government." Critically Examine.

Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023

The Indian independence historiography is highly divided on the motive of Britishers behind granting India independence.

Motives behind independence

1. fulfilment of Indian self government - a) As per Phillip Woods, granting of Independence was the culmination of step by step process. - b) The acts such as Morley Minto reforms, Montague Chelmsford and GOI Act 1935 aided in the development of self government in India. - c) V.P Menon argued that India's independence was a parting gift of Labour government to India , who were sympathetic towards India. 2. Britain compelled to transfer power - a) As per Carl Bridge and Tomlinson , the British before 1946 never wanted to transfer power. - b) The acts were brought to satisfy demands as well as divide the Indians. - c) The WW II greatly weakened Britain and its ability to hold on to India. - d) Moreover, pressure from US, USSR also helped in liberation of India. - e) The mass discontent and virulent Quit India movement also reduced british morale and forced them to quit India.

Thus, independence of India cannot be simply categorized as fulfilment of self-rule. However, sympathetic labour government, internal-external issued helped in Indian decolonization